Tuesday, July 5, 2022
No Result
View All Result
Asbarez.com
NEWSLETTER
ՀԱՅ
  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Community
  • Arts & Culture
    • Art
    • Books
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Critics’ Forum
  • Op-Ed
    • Editorial
    • Opinon
    • Letters
  • Columns
    • By Any Means
    • My Turn
    • Three Apples
    • Community Links
    • Critics’ Forum
    • My Name is Armen
    • Living in Armenia
  • Videos
  • Sports
  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Community
  • Arts & Culture
    • Art
    • Books
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Critics’ Forum
  • Op-Ed
    • Editorial
    • Opinon
    • Letters
  • Columns
    • By Any Means
    • My Turn
    • Three Apples
    • Community Links
    • Critics’ Forum
    • My Name is Armen
    • Living in Armenia
  • Videos
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Asbarez.com
ՀԱՅ
No Result
View All Result

The Murder of Hrach Muradian and its Aftermath: A Detailed Report

by Contributor
August 8, 2013
in Armenia, Featured Story, Latest, Top Stories
4
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Proshian mayor Hratch Muradian during an AYF Youth Corps camp event in the village

BY SAMSON MARTIROSYAN
From The Armenian Weekly

The village of Proshian, situated in Kotayk province, just outside of Yerevan, has a population of about 5,000 people. The Proshian Brandy Factory, which is famous for the high-quality grapes and apricots it uses, is right in the village center. The villagers of Proshian lived a relatively quiet life up until four months ago, when an unknown assailant gunned down their mayor.

On April 2, Hrach Muradian, 50, was shot dead. His body was found at 9 a.m. in front of the municipality building. The bullet had hit him straight in the head, leaving no chance for survival.

Born to a repatriate family from Syria, Muradian was an active member of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) and had been re-elected mayor of Proshian three terms since 2005. Muradian was also a Karabagh War veteran and one of the founders of the Shushi Special Unit, and was awarded the Artshakh Martakan Khach. He was married, and had two sons and two daughters.

Muradian’s murder was a real shock not only for Proshian, but for the entire country. On April 4, a candlelight vigil was held near Yerevan’s Opera House. Many high-ranking members of the ARF, as well as leaders of the Sardarabat movement and other civil activists, were present that day. Many came with posters, condemning his death.

The ARF immediately qualified the murder as a politically driven, intentional assassination, and said it was evidence that no one’s security was guaranteed. The Armenian National Congress (ANC) also condemned the murder and stressed the motive was clearly political—a consequence of the environment created by a corrupt and autocratic system. Jirayr Sefilyan, the leader of the Sardarapat movement, said the murder was the result of the criminal mindset and atmosphere of impunity that surrounds the ruling elite. Meanwhile, Heritage Party leader Raffi Hovhannisian, who was present at Muradian’s funeral, said it was a blow to Armenia’s statehood, to the Armenian nation, and to every Armenian.

According to the ARF and many Proshian villagers, during Muradian’s tenure, tensions were high between the ARF and the ruling Republican Party (RPA). Muradian was well respected and had managed to gain the trust of the majority of the population, allowing him to win local elections and beat RPA candidates time and again. In September 2012, his rival was RPA member Artur Muradian. When Hrach Muradian won the elections, the situation deteriorated. The village became divided into two camps: those who affiliated themselves with the RPA, and those (the majority of the population) who supported Hrach Muradian. Even during Muradian’s post-election celebration party, a skirmish broke out between his loyalists and a group of men who were reportedly RPA supporters.

The mayor and his family realized they were in harm’s way—even before 2012. His family says that in 2010, a hay stack was deliberately set aflame in an attempt to burn down their farm. Firemen did later confirm that the fire was an act of arson. In 2010, another grave incident shook the mayor when someone attempted to kidnap his nephew. That attempt ended in a scuffle. According to Melanya Arustamyan, Muradian’s family lawyer, when the mayor emerged from his residence following the kidnapping attempt, someone shot at his nephew and his car. The mayor himself later faced charges following speculation that he had shot at his own car as an act of provocation.

While the ARF, and many other political actors, qualified Muradian’s murder as a politically driven assassination, it was apparent that the accusations and hints indirectly pointed at the RPA. That party did not issue an official statement; when the media urged some of its representatives to react, they denied any involvement.

The story of this murder is marked with ambiguous events. And the greater the controversy it caused, the greater the bewilderment and anger among the people.

On April 4, police announced that they had detained the Petrosyan brothers—Arthur, 33, and Arayik, 31—after interrogating dozens of people and searching several houses. The next day, news spread that Arayik Petrosyan faced charges and criminal proceedings under Articles 104, 2.2 (murder of the person of close relative of the latter, due to service and public duty of the person) and 235, 1 (illegal procurement, transportation, keeping or carrying of weapons, explosives or explosive devices, except smoothbore long-barrel hunting guns, ammunition) of Armenia’s criminal code. The case was placed under the jurisdiction of the Chief Investigation Department of the Police for Particularly Important Cases. A day later, the Kentron, Norq-Marash Court of First Instance ordered Arayik’s arrest.

As the investigation continued, police presented their main piece of evidence: traces of metallic antimony (a metalloid used in the production of bullets) on Petrosyan’s sleeves and face, and in the car he had used on the day of the murder. Once such a bullet is fired, it leaves behind a particular trace. This remains the main evidence against Petrosyan.

Petrosyan’s lawyer, Givi Hovhannisyan, lodged a complaint with the Court of Appeals asking to review the decision to arrest Petrosyan. Hovhannisyan also repeatedly claimed that the investigation was carried out in an inappropriate manner: Traces of antimony cannot be considered hard evidence against his client, he argued, as the police had not proven that they had come from a gunshot. He also said that the expiration date of the antimony had not been noted in the examination.

According to Hovhannisyan, antimony is used not only in bullet production, but also in many other household chemicals, and is even found in nature. He also argued that whereas a bullet leaves behind traces of other chemicals, the examination report had only mentioned antimony. Petrosyan’s wife later testified that he had been working on his car for several days before the murder—which could result in traces of antimony.

The police have another clue: Petrosyan was seen driving a white Lada Niva the day of the crime, the same type of car that was spotted near the murder scene. Hovhannisyan, however, argues that Petrosyan’s car was broken down and that he had to borrow his friend’s car, a white Niva.

Petrosyan’s wife testified that on the day of the murder, her husband took their children to school at around 8:20 a.m., came back at 8:30 a.m., and stayed home until about 9:20 a.m., when he left to go to work. She claims her neighbors saw him.

There are other curious factors as well. Neither the murder weapon, nor the cartridge case have been found. When police searched the Petrosyan brothers’ houses, they found a hunting gun, but subsequent examination proved that the bullet had come from a different gun. Also, nobody seems to have heard the sound of a gunshot, hinting at the use of a silencer. Many argue that if Muradian was the victim of a drive-by shooting, the car involved would have been spotted as it drove away. Yet, nobody saw a car, except for the white Niva that was later spotted by police in the area. If Muradian was shot in the head from a distance, then the killer was likely a professional hit-man. Petrosyan doesn’t fit the bill, since he is not a professional shooter, he physically cannot be placed at the murder scene, and has no witnesses against him.

There are also numerous accounts that describe Petrosyan and Muradian as having good relations. In fact, Arayik Petrosyan could enter the mayor’s office without registering in advance. Many have said that there were no conflicts between the two.

As mentioned, the police also detained Arayik’s brother Artak, later released him, and detained him again. He is currently in custody. Artak is facing charges of hooliganism. According to police, he was present at the September 2012 skirmish that followed Muradian’s election victory. The case was closed over the absence of corpus delicti, but the prosecutor’s office re-launched it. Artak Petrosyan denies he was there. The case is now under the jurisdiction of the Chief Department of Investigation, even though cases of hooliganism are, as a rule, not investigated by this department. Both family members and the lawyer insist that this was done deliberately to create an artificial link between the 2012 event and the 2013 murder, and to then prove that a confrontation between the Petrosyans and Muradian had started in September 2012.

On April 17, the brothers’ father wrote an open letter to President Serge Sarkisian, Prosecutor General Aghvan Hovsepyan, and Chief of Police Vova Gasparyan. In his letter, he thoroughly explained what had transpired and demanded that the investigation be placed under their direct control. He asked that they do everything to guarantee maximum transparency and to ensure that law enforcement bodies use the law to its fullest to solve this case as soon as possible and relieve his family from anguish.

On April 18, the day of Arayik Petrosyan’s arrest hearing and the decision by the Court of Appeals, many demonstrated in Proshian in support of the brothers. People held posters that read, “Arayik is not guilty,” and “Set them free.” The protesters marched from Proshian to the Court of Appeals, where they waited for the court’s decision.

The Court of Appeals turned down Hovhannisyan’s demands, and upheld the previous decision of Kentron, Norq-Marash Court of First Instance to arrest Petrosyan. His wife and lawyer said they are determined to fight until they clear his name, and are even willing to appeal to the European Court of Human Rights if they are unable to reach justice in the Armenian courts.

Two months later, at the end of May, Kentron, Norq-Marash Court of First Instance passed a decision to prolong Petrosyan’s arrest for two more months, at the request of law enforcement bodies. No new evidence was presented; his arrest was again based on the previous evidence of antimony traces on his body and in his car. This caused another wave of anger and rage among many. Hovhannisyan announced that for two months Arayik had not been interrogated.

Two ARF Parliamentary members (MPs), Armen Rustamyan and Aghvan Vardanyan, met with police chief Vova Gasparyan to discuss the murder case and any developments. Gasparyan said he would do everything within his means to ensure that justice is reached and the case is solved. Some, however, believe the opposite to be true; to them, it seems the police and the courts are intent on finding the brothers guilty.

Immediately after the meeting between the police chief and the ARF representatives, the police announced that they would give a reward of $5,000 to any person who could offer significant information regarding the case. The police assured the public that they would protect the identity of the informer. So far, however, no one has responded to their call. Some fear that sooner or later, someone might fabricate information to claim the promised sum, further complicating the investigation.

The brothers’ lawyer has revealed that a new investigation is currently underway, giving cause to doubt the results from the first one. Petrosyan’s arrest term expires in August, and while the findings from the first investigation were made available after only a day, it has been more than two weeks since second investigation ended. Law enforcement may apply to the court to prolong Petrosyan’s term.

With the support of the ARF and its MP, Aghvan Vardanyan, the “Demand Justice for Hrach Muradian” civic movement was created. The main aim of this movement is to achieve justice, and to ensure that the case receives broad coverage by the mainstream media so that the public is informed of any further developments.

Special elections for a new mayor were held in Proshian on July 14. Three candidates vied for the position: Aleksan Aleksanyan, non-partisan; Vova Sahakyan, ARF affiliated; and Artur Muradian, an RPA member. The ARF did not officially back Sahakyan, who was the main opposition runner against the RPA candidate. In a tough competition, the RPA’s Artur Muradian was elected mayor. According to the official election results, he received 1,371 votes against Sahakyan’s 1,241 votes. This election, as with any other election in Armenia, was carried out in an extremely tense environment. The RPA reportedly bribed voters and enlisted the help of law enforcement to secure a win. Both Aleksan Aleksanyan and Vova Sahakyan rejected the election results.

Many now view Artur Muradian’s victory as the RPA’s ultimate objective—a vicious, power-grabbing policy that led to Muradian’s murder and the Petrosyan brothers’ victimization. From the moment Artur Muradian was elected into office, the village of Proshian belonged to the RPA. No one remains to challenge its supremacy.

Just days after the new elections, protesters took to the streets in Proshian to rail against the arrest and detention of the Petrosyan brothers. They submitted a petition with 980 signatures to the prosecutor general, Aghvan Hovsepyan, demanding that the case be revived, the investigation accelerated, and transparency assured. Meanwhile, Arayik Petrosyan’s wife has threatened self-immolation if her husband is found guilty. That potential verdict, she said, would leave their four children without paternal care, and would signify the failure of justice in the country.

In the days following Artur Muradian’s election, 13 local officials resigned in protest. The new mayor, however, did not view this as a problem; as he said, the staff was replaceable. Is there anyone who doubts it? Is there anyone who expected a proper, decent reaction? Surely not, as it is naive to expect a different reaction from a member of the ruling elite.

Unfortunately, the story of this murder and what followed are indicative of the “democratic” processes in place in Armenia. Where there is political will, there is little that stands in the way of its implementation, regardless of the consequences. The executive and judicial branches of power can—and have—easily become tools in the hands of the powerful. The system of checks and balances seems to have been completely forgotten. Law enforcement officials have proven to be mere puppets in a big theatre. And those individuals who oppose the system of impunity are faced with terrible consequences, and no practical guarantees of their fundamental rights.

Sometimes the system is deliberately managed only semi-repressively, as opposed to total repression, thereby giving the semblance of progress where there is none. Most of the time, like in the case of Hrach Muradian’s murder, the system operates in a perfectly repressive manner, with all necessary resources directed against the very existence of the opposition.

The Armenian Weekly will continue following this case very closely to see if it is carried out fairly and in a way that promotes justice.

***

Two months after the murder, an unknown person(s) defiled a monument at the gravesite of slain mayor Hrach Muradian and Proshian’s many other war veterans. The words “The Spectacle Is Over” (Հանդեսը Վերջացած է) were written across the monument. The type of paint used made it impossible to erase the graffiti. Villagers found those words on the 40th day (քառասունք) after Muradian’s death․ Muradian’s family, along with many others, believe this was done by the real culprits, as their way of celebrating their victory.

This detailed report was prepared by Samson Martirosyan, The Armenian Weekly’s correspondent in Gyumri.

Contributor

Contributor

Next Post

Ventura Armenian Apostolic Church Plans Gala Dinner Dance

Comments 4

  1. Mihran says:
    9 years ago

    Make no mistake the evil and corrupt hand of serzh’s ruling RPA party is all over this and other murders in Armenia,the RPA id the root cause of all evil in Armenia now,from immigration to daily injustices,from corruption to murder.

    Reply
  2. www.Voskanapat.info says:
    9 years ago

    I understand that political assassination is the leading explanation for this murder. I would like to know if any other versions were explored. Robbery? Business dealings? Family disputes? If this is article is billed as a “detailed report” why doesn’t it cover all possible scenarios?

    Reply
  3. bigmoustache says:
    9 years ago

    where is the ARF of my fathers generation? the ones I used to hear great stories about in Lebanon?
    if the ARF in Yerevan is impotent then let us run it from the diaspora! I call on the old guard of the ARF in Lebanon to act, justice and revenge are needed! Armenia needs you!

    Reply
  4. HAIK says:
    9 years ago

    My father told me years ago…when an Armenian murders a fellow Armenian, he is no longer Armenian he is now and always a Turk! Until something is done about the rampant corruption in that country and the murderous animals in all segments of the society, the future will be bleak!

    Reply

Leave a Reply to HAIK Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Study Points to Armenian Origins of Ancient Crop With Aviation Biofuel Potential

Study Points to Armenian Origins of Ancient Crop With Aviation Biofuel Potential

2 hours ago
Opposition Blasts EU’s ‘Double Standards’

Opposition Again Slams EU

3 hours ago

Connect with us

  • About
  • Advertising
  • Subscribe
  • Contact

© 2021 Asbarez | All Rights Reserved | Powered By MSDN Solutions Inc.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Community
  • Arts & Culture
    • Art
    • Books
    • Music
    • Theatre
    • Critics’ Forum
  • Op-Ed
    • Editorial
    • Opinon
    • Letters
  • Columns
    • By Any Means
    • My Turn
    • Three Apples
    • Community Links
    • Critics’ Forum
    • My Name is Armen
    • Living in Armenia
  • Videos
  • Sports

© 2021 Asbarez | All Rights Reserved | Powered By MSDN Solutions Inc.

Accessibility

Accessibility modes

Epilepsy Safe Mode
Dampens color and removes blinks
This mode enables people with epilepsy to use the website safely by eliminating the risk of seizures that result from flashing or blinking animations and risky color combinations.
Visually Impaired Mode
Improves website's visuals
This mode adjusts the website for the convenience of users with visual impairments such as Degrading Eyesight, Tunnel Vision, Cataract, Glaucoma, and others.
Cognitive Disability Mode
Helps to focus on specific content
This mode provides different assistive options to help users with cognitive impairments such as Dyslexia, Autism, CVA, and others, to focus on the essential elements of the website more easily.
ADHD Friendly Mode
Reduces distractions and improve focus
This mode helps users with ADHD and Neurodevelopmental disorders to read, browse, and focus on the main website elements more easily while significantly reducing distractions.
Blindness Mode
Allows using the site with your screen-reader
This mode configures the website to be compatible with screen-readers such as JAWS, NVDA, VoiceOver, and TalkBack. A screen-reader is software for blind users that is installed on a computer and smartphone, and websites must be compatible with it.

Online Dictionary

    Readable Experience

    Content Scaling
    Default
    Text Magnifier
    Readable Font
    Dyslexia Friendly
    Highlight Titles
    Highlight Links
    Font Sizing
    Default
    Line Height
    Default
    Letter Spacing
    Default
    Left Aligned
    Center Aligned
    Right Aligned

    Visually Pleasing Experience

    Dark Contrast
    Light Contrast
    Monochrome
    High Contrast
    High Saturation
    Low Saturation
    Adjust Text Colors
    Adjust Title Colors
    Adjust Background Colors

    Easy Orientation

    Mute Sounds
    Hide Images
    Virtual Keyboard
    Reading Guide
    Stop Animations
    Reading Mask
    Highlight Hover
    Highlight Focus
    Big Dark Cursor
    Big Light Cursor
    Navigation Keys

    Asbarez.com Accessibility Statement

    Accessibility Statement

    • www.asbarez.com
    • July 5, 2022

    Compliance status

    We firmly believe that the internet should be available and accessible to anyone, and are committed to providing a website that is accessible to the widest possible audience, regardless of circumstance and ability.

    To fulfill this, we aim to adhere as strictly as possible to the World Wide Web Consortium’s (W3C) Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1 (WCAG 2.1) at the AA level. These guidelines explain how to make web content accessible to people with a wide array of disabilities. Complying with those guidelines helps us ensure that the website is accessible to all people: blind people, people with motor impairments, visual impairment, cognitive disabilities, and more.

    This website utilizes various technologies that are meant to make it as accessible as possible at all times. We utilize an accessibility interface that allows persons with specific disabilities to adjust the website’s UI (user interface) and design it to their personal needs.

    Additionally, the website utilizes an AI-based application that runs in the background and optimizes its accessibility level constantly. This application remediates the website’s HTML, adapts Its functionality and behavior for screen-readers used by the blind users, and for keyboard functions used by individuals with motor impairments.

    If you’ve found a malfunction or have ideas for improvement, we’ll be happy to hear from you. You can reach out to the website’s operators by using the following email

    Screen-reader and keyboard navigation

    Our website implements the ARIA attributes (Accessible Rich Internet Applications) technique, alongside various different behavioral changes, to ensure blind users visiting with screen-readers are able to read, comprehend, and enjoy the website’s functions. As soon as a user with a screen-reader enters your site, they immediately receive a prompt to enter the Screen-Reader Profile so they can browse and operate your site effectively. Here’s how our website covers some of the most important screen-reader requirements, alongside console screenshots of code examples:

    1. Screen-reader optimization: we run a background process that learns the website’s components from top to bottom, to ensure ongoing compliance even when updating the website. In this process, we provide screen-readers with meaningful data using the ARIA set of attributes. For example, we provide accurate form labels; descriptions for actionable icons (social media icons, search icons, cart icons, etc.); validation guidance for form inputs; element roles such as buttons, menus, modal dialogues (popups), and others. Additionally, the background process scans all of the website’s images and provides an accurate and meaningful image-object-recognition-based description as an ALT (alternate text) tag for images that are not described. It will also extract texts that are embedded within the image, using an OCR (optical character recognition) technology. To turn on screen-reader adjustments at any time, users need only to press the Alt+1 keyboard combination. Screen-reader users also get automatic announcements to turn the Screen-reader mode on as soon as they enter the website.

      These adjustments are compatible with all popular screen readers, including JAWS and NVDA.

    2. Keyboard navigation optimization: The background process also adjusts the website’s HTML, and adds various behaviors using JavaScript code to make the website operable by the keyboard. This includes the ability to navigate the website using the Tab and Shift+Tab keys, operate dropdowns with the arrow keys, close them with Esc, trigger buttons and links using the Enter key, navigate between radio and checkbox elements using the arrow keys, and fill them in with the Spacebar or Enter key.Additionally, keyboard users will find quick-navigation and content-skip menus, available at any time by clicking Alt+1, or as the first elements of the site while navigating with the keyboard. The background process also handles triggered popups by moving the keyboard focus towards them as soon as they appear, and not allow the focus drift outside of it.

      Users can also use shortcuts such as “M” (menus), “H” (headings), “F” (forms), “B” (buttons), and “G” (graphics) to jump to specific elements.

    Disability profiles supported in our website

    • Epilepsy Safe Mode: this profile enables people with epilepsy to use the website safely by eliminating the risk of seizures that result from flashing or blinking animations and risky color combinations.
    • Visually Impaired Mode: this mode adjusts the website for the convenience of users with visual impairments such as Degrading Eyesight, Tunnel Vision, Cataract, Glaucoma, and others.
    • Cognitive Disability Mode: this mode provides different assistive options to help users with cognitive impairments such as Dyslexia, Autism, CVA, and others, to focus on the essential elements of the website more easily.
    • ADHD Friendly Mode: this mode helps users with ADHD and Neurodevelopmental disorders to read, browse, and focus on the main website elements more easily while significantly reducing distractions.
    • Blindness Mode: this mode configures the website to be compatible with screen-readers such as JAWS, NVDA, VoiceOver, and TalkBack. A screen-reader is software for blind users that is installed on a computer and smartphone, and websites must be compatible with it.
    • Keyboard Navigation Profile (Motor-Impaired): this profile enables motor-impaired persons to operate the website using the keyboard Tab, Shift+Tab, and the Enter keys. Users can also use shortcuts such as “M” (menus), “H” (headings), “F” (forms), “B” (buttons), and “G” (graphics) to jump to specific elements.

    Additional UI, design, and readability adjustments

    1. Font adjustments – users, can increase and decrease its size, change its family (type), adjust the spacing, alignment, line height, and more.
    2. Color adjustments – users can select various color contrast profiles such as light, dark, inverted, and monochrome. Additionally, users can swap color schemes of titles, texts, and backgrounds, with over 7 different coloring options.
    3. Animations – epileptic users can stop all running animations with the click of a button. Animations controlled by the interface include videos, GIFs, and CSS flashing transitions.
    4. Content highlighting – users can choose to emphasize important elements such as links and titles. They can also choose to highlight focused or hovered elements only.
    5. Audio muting – users with hearing devices may experience headaches or other issues due to automatic audio playing. This option lets users mute the entire website instantly.
    6. Cognitive disorders – we utilize a search engine that is linked to Wikipedia and Wiktionary, allowing people with cognitive disorders to decipher meanings of phrases, initials, slang, and others.
    7. Additional functions – we provide users the option to change cursor color and size, use a printing mode, enable a virtual keyboard, and many other functions.

    Browser and assistive technology compatibility

    We aim to support the widest array of browsers and assistive technologies as possible, so our users can choose the best fitting tools for them, with as few limitations as possible. Therefore, we have worked very hard to be able to support all major systems that comprise over 95% of the user market share including Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, Apple Safari, Opera and Microsoft Edge, JAWS and NVDA (screen readers), both for Windows and for MAC users.

    Notes, comments, and feedback

    Despite our very best efforts to allow anybody to adjust the website to their needs, there may still be pages or sections that are not fully accessible, are in the process of becoming accessible, or are lacking an adequate technological solution to make them accessible. Still, we are continually improving our accessibility, adding, updating and improving its options and features, and developing and adopting new technologies. All this is meant to reach the optimal level of accessibility, following technological advancements. For any assistance, please reach out to